Close X


Integrity of Breath Testing Threatened in DUI Cases in Washington

Posted by Unknown | Mar 04, 2014 | 0 Comments

Dr. Barry Logan, head of the agency responsible for assuring the reliability of breath testing in this state, has acknowledged that the lab manager of the State Toxicology lab falsely signed an undetermined number of legal certificates since 2002 saying she had checked the solution used to confirm that breath testing machines are accurately measuring the alcohol content of breath.  Not surprisingly, Dr. Logan has asserted that this conduct does not affect the accuracy of the breath testing machines involved, virtually every machine in the state.

Unfortunately, Dr. Logan has missed the point.  The issue is the integrity of the system.  The public, and of course the accused, have the absolute right to expect objective, accurate and TRUTHFUL information from every branch of government, but particularly from an agency whose reports can determine the fate of those citizens who are accused of a crime and whose liberty, reputation and career are threatened.

Here is a copy of the original article that was posted in the Olympian:

Drunken driving cases disputed

Attorneys promise challenges after lab manager's resignation

by Adam Wilson
The Olympian

Evidence in drunken driving cases across the state are likely to be challenged because of questions about the state's toxicology lab manager's role in checking breath analyzers, defense attorneys say.

The Washington State Patrol and prosecutors say the former manager's failure to personally check batches of a solution used in breath analyzers has no effect on the machines' accuracy, because other analysts did test the solution.

But the lab manager, Ann Marie Gordon, signed an undetermined number of legal certificates since 2002 saying she had checked the solution. It is used by police officers to confirm their machines are accurately measuring the amount of alcohol in a person's breath.

“Defense attorneys across the state now are going to challenge the admissibility of the breath tests,” said Bill Bowman, president-elect of the Washington Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.

“The bigger implication, in my opinion, is to the credibility of the state,” he added, explaining the state toxicology lab is expected to produce objective, accurate information for use by both the accused person and prosecutors.

“Because now her honesty is in question, any tests she had done, including blood work, could be challenged. Personal credibility is at issue,” Bowman said.

Gordon could not be reached for comment.

Barry Logan, director of the patrol's Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau, confirmed Gordon's resignation last week. He said her practices as manager were under investigation, but declined to elaborate.

Because the solutions in question are inspected by several analysts at the Seattle lab, they are still valid, said Whitman County Prosecutor Denis Tracy.

“If there was a problem where she said it was tested and it wasn't, there's still eight or nine redundant tests by other analysts,” Tracy said.

Tracy wrote a terse letter to the crime lab after he learned blood evidence in a Whitman County case, the vehicular homicide trial of Frederick Russell, had been destroyed. Russell was apprehended in Ireland in 2005 and was returned to Washington.

Logan, Gordon's supervisor, testified in a recent hearing in Russell's case that Gordon had accidentally destroyed the evidence three years after the crash in question, but before Russell was brought to trial.

That news came in the same week that Gordon resigned, but Tracy said he knew of no connection between the Russell case and her departure.

“I'm aware of the situation. It happens to be the same time as the Frederick Russell case, but they're not related,” said Lanna Weinmann, the Attorney General's Office lawyer leading the Russell prosecution.

Gordon's departure and the State Patrol's decision to remove her certificates from its online database mean more than just challenging breath test results, said Scott Wonder, a Bellevue attorney who handles drunken driving cases.

“Ms. Gordon was the supervisor for all kinds of breath and blood tests,” he said. “It makes you wonder at the very least what corners she cut.”

Adam Wilson covers state workers and politics for The Olympian. He can be reached at 360-753-1688 or [email protected].

About the Author


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Cowan Kirk Kattenhorn

Cowan Kirk is known throughout Washington and the nation for representing all of its clients with commitment, creativity and compassion. We recognize how devastating a DUI charge can be, particularly when our clients learn how incredibly tough Washington's DUI laws have become, even for a first-time offender.

Contact Us

If you need a DUI defense attorney in Seattle, Bellevue, or King County, contact us today to find out why respect for our clients, a passion for justice, and our commitment to winning have earned each of us the highest honor a member of the bar can receive from our colleagues – their referrals.